Movie Rewind – Review: Tooth Fairy

Release Date: January 22, 2010
Running Time: 120 minutes
Rating: PG

Starring: Dwayne Johnson, Julie Andrews, Ashley Judd, Stephen Merchant, Ryan Sheckler, Chase Ellison, Destiny Whitlock

Dwayne Johnson stars in Tooth Fairy as Derek Thompson, one of the toughest hockey players around — until he’s sentenced to one week’s hard labor as the world’s most unlikely tooth fairy! Even though he must sport frilly wings and learn the magical tricks of the trade from his silver-winged superiors (Julie Andrews and Billy Crystal), Derek’s determined to do the job HIS way and prove he’s got what it takes!

Looking at Dwayne Johnson’s acting resume, it seems that he tends to play arrogant characters who eventually learn to acknowledge that they have a heart. His character is no different in this film and it works. It’s very amusing to watch the different lengths Derek goes through to get the teeth from children before he embraces his new gig.

As for the rest of the cast…Ashley Judd’s appearance in the film isn’t as fulfilling as one would think. Her character, Lily comes off a bit cartoonish with her facial expressions. Aside from this, there’s more depth from the two young actors who play her children than there is with her character. Julie Andrews was obviously typecast but it works well. Seth MacFarlane, Brandon T. Jackson, and Billy Crystal can also be seen in the film and they all shine equally. Then there’s Stephen Merchant, who is the highlight of the film. He definitely steals the comedic light from Johnson and based on his writing credits, could have been a better suit as sole screenwriter for this film.

Unfortunately, Merchant’s only role in this film was to act. It’s a shame because 5 screenwriters were credited for Tooth Fairy, which could have been a much better film, especially considering that the film had been in development since 1992.

While very much enjoyable for children and a pleasant surprise for adults, this feel good family comedy is all too predictable for this day and age. There are recycled tricks, too many puns, a few wacky special effects, and the typical feel good talent show ending. Viewers will find themselves laughing out loud throughout but they won’t walk away feeling as though the film has made a huge impression.

There are lessons to be learned but because of the simple screenwriting, this film is by no means profound It has a bit of heart as it inspires everyone of all ages to not be afraid to dream, go after those dreams, and encourage your loved ones to dream. But it just does not compare well with other inspiring sports films or modern day family driven fairy tales such as Santa Claus and Elf when it comes to heart. Though in the end, enough teeth are filled to reach a grin at the end.

Standout Scene: Derek uses fairy (amnesia) dust on his girlfriend, Lily when the two are discussing taking their relationship to the next level. Luckily, it only takes Derek a handful of times to get to the right answer.